For many years, as interest rates were very depressed thanks in no small part to the Federal Reserve’s quantitative easing program, money market mutual funds had puny yields. But that’s reversed. To fight inflation, the Federal Open Market Committee has aggressively raised short-term rates since early last year, effectively boosting yields across the bond market. Money market funds have been a big beneficiary. Assets total about $6 trillion, an all-time record. For some perspective on these funds, which typically invest in shorter-term securities such as Treasury bills, Income Matters Today spoke with Peter Crane, a leading expert on these funds. This is an edited version of that conversation.
Peter Crane, head of Crane Data.
Income Matters Today: What’s important for retail investors to be thinking about when it comes to money market mutual funds?
Peter Crane: Money markets and cash are just for money that you might need tomorrow – the shortest-term and the safest investment bucket. Money market mutual funds, which aren’t bank deposits and aren’t insured by the FDIC [Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation], became popular because bank interest rates stunk in the past. They are not very good now, in most cases. Money funds got to be a $6 trillion vehicle because they give investors what the market gives them. That’s an important point that has been lost. Often with investing, you have to know where the market is. If the market is paying 5.25% and you’re getting 5%, you’re good. If the market’s paying 2% and you are getting 5%, you are taking a major risk – and there’s something wrong with that. So that market rate of return has been the key to the success of money market mutual funds. And, of course, they offer convenience – notably liquidity and safety.
Editor’s note: Liquidity refers to being able to withdraw cash from a fund quickly, typically in a single business day. Separately, bank deposits are insured at up to at least $250,000 per depositor, per FDIC-insured bank, per ownership category, according to the FDIC’s Website.
Money market yields have been very attractive lately at around 5% on average, but that wasn’t the case for many years with ultra-low interest rates.
Prior to early last year when the Fed started hiking short-term rates, money market rates had been almost zero for 14 out of the last 17 years. So, we’ve come through an unusual period of zero yields.
Historically, money funds have had a yield advantage over bank deposits. Bank deposits, though, had a safety advantage, owing to the FDIC protection, but that’s sort of shifted. Of course, when there’s no yield, all you care about is safety and liquidity.
But now that money funds are almost entirely invested in government securities such as Treasuries, that safety differential has changed as well.
U.S money market fund assets have surged to $6 trillion. What’s driving that?
The assets keep hitting records every day. Money market fund inflows show no signs of stopping. The retail flows are being driven by money trying to get a competitive rate. That’s brokerage money moving out of bank sweep [accounts] and into money funds. It’s also high net-worth money and institutional money coming in. Those 5% yields are definitely bringing in a lot of cash. Retail assets have been growing at 40% over the last year; institutional at 15%.
Where are the money market flows coming from right now?
Most of the money in money markets isn’t going into the stock market; it’s being used for different personal finance business purposes and cash. Most of the money we’ve seen coming into money markets this year isn’t coming out of the stock market; it’s coming out of bank deposits. In general, everybody, because the markets have done so well over the past 20, 30 years, is overweight stocks and bonds and underweighted cash. But the world’s still a dangerous place. If investors don’t have that cash cushion – and if they don’t have that emergency buying power -- it’s a great time to reconsider that.
But it's bank deposits that have been the main driver of money market mutual fund flows these days, because bank deposit rates are so low generally.
What kind of yields are you seeing?
The Crane 100 money fund index, which is an average of the largest funds, was 5.16% as of Sept. 14. It’s sort of flatlined there over the last two, three weeks as the most recent Fed hike in late July gets digested.
Have you seen any other factors contribute to the pick up in money market fund inflows?
They’ve gradually been building for the last year and a few months. In March, when you saw the Silicon Valley Bank tremor, and concerns about the health of regional banks you had a big shift of institutional assets. Until the government guarantees all bank deposits, that uninsured deposit slice remains vulnerable. It’s still around $7 trillion out of the $18 trillion total.
Editor’s note: The U.S. Securities And Exchange Commission recently approved amendments to some of its rules for these funds, partly owing to concerns about transparency and liquidity. SEC Chairperson Gary Gensler noted in a July statement outlining the proposals that there’s “a potential structural liquidity mismatch” for money market funds.“Investors can redeem their money market fund holdings on a daily basis, even if those funds keep some of their holdings in securities with less liquidity,” he added.
The new rules attempt to shore that up. There have been a few times – during the financial crisis in 2008 and early in the pandemic in March of 2020 – when liquidity surfaced as an issue. What’s important to keep in mind here?
The SEC has changed Rule 2a-7 of the Investment Company Act of 1940 a number of times since the birth of money funds a little over 50 years ago. This latest round increases the liquidity requirements so you’re going to see even more government money funds – that means more Treasury bill holdings and the like. During the last couple of rounds of rule changes, you saw a big shift away from credit [securities] and into government holdings to make them safter. Most of the technical changes relate primarily to the prime institutional funds, whose holdings can include commercial paper, and certificates of deposit, corporate notes. Retail investors as a whole, though, won’t see that much change in money funds.
What kinds of holdings are you seeing in government money market funds catering to retail investors?
The weighted average for how long it takes a money fund to turn over its portfolio is 25 days. So even a one-month Treasury bill is longer than that. But one- and three-month Treasury bills are usually what you are looking at for a lot of the holdings in these particular funds.
We should have started with this at the top. You are the first guest that Income Matters Today has interviewed!
It’s a privilege and thrill to be here. Best of luck with everything.
Thanks, Peter. We appreciate your good wishes and the perspective.
DISCLAIMER:
LCS76 LLC, a Delaware limited liability company (the “Company”), and its affiliates do not provide tax, legal or accounting advice. The information and material provided on lawrencestrauss.substack.com (the “Website”) has been prepared for informational purposes only, and is shall not be understood, nor construed, as tax, legal or accounting advice. You should consult your own tax, legal and accounting advisors before engaging in any transaction. Lawrence Strauss (“Strauss”) is not an attorney, accountant or financial advisor, nor is he holding himself out to be, and the information contained on this Website is not a substitute for financial advice from a professional who is aware of the facts and circumstances of your individual situation, investment objectives, and financial situation. Neither Strauss, the Company nor any of their respective employees, agents, owners, representatives successors, and assigns shall be held liable or responsible for any errors or omissions on this website or for any damage you may suffer as a result of failing to seek competent tax, financial, or legal advice from a professional who is familiar with your situation.
By assessing the Website and the information contained herein, you agree that: (i) neither the Company, Strauss, nor any of their respective employees or owners has made any guarantees about the results of taking any action, whether recommended on this Website or not; (ii) your ultimate success or failure will be the result of your own efforts, your particular situation, and innumerable other circumstances beyond the control and/or knowledge of the Company; (iii) you should be aware of the real risk of loss in following any strategy or investment discussed on this Website; and (iv) investments or strategies mentioned on this Website may not be suitable for you. You nevertheless recognize that your ultimate success or failure will be the result of your own efforts, your particular situation, and innumerable other circumstances beyond the control and/or knowledge of the Company.
BY ASSESSING THE WEBSITE AND THE INFORMATION CONTAINED HEREIN, YOU AGREE TO ABSOLVE THE COMPANY, STRAUSS, AND THEIR RESPECTIVE EMPLOYEES, AGENTS, OWNERS, REPRESENTATIVES, SUCCESSORS, AND ASSIGNS OF ANY AND ALL LIABILITY OR LOSS THAT YOU OR ANY PERSON OR ENTITY ASSOCIATED WITH YOU MAY SUFFER OR INCUR AS A RESULT OF USE OF THE INFORMATION CONTAINED ON THIS WEBSITE AND/OR THE RESOURCES YOU MAY DOWNLOAD FROM THIS WEBSITE, INCLUDING, WITHOUT LIMITATION, ANY DIRECT, INDIRECT, SPECIAL, INCIDENTAL, EQUITABLE, OR CONSEQUENTIAL LOSS OR DAMAGES FOR USE OF THIS WEBSITE OR THE INFORMATION CONTAINED HEREIN.